[chrishajer]

[EDIT – I posted this AFTER atsutane posted, but that reply was in the spam queue erroneously, so this probably looks weird now that atsutane’s reply is visible ]

Did you ask for help on the plugin page?

https://bbpress.org/plugins/topic/bbcode-buttons/page/5/

Plugin authors typically see requests there even if they don’t see them here.

But if I remember correctly, that plugin just provided the buttons. You still need to provide a bbcode plugin for your installation. Something like this? https://bbpress.org/plugins/topic/bbcode-lite/

The theme and version of bbPress are not causing the problem. Thanks.