[joeyaberle]

I have entered 10 under the Topics and Replies Per Page in Forum Settings. Yet, my most popular topic is showing a total of 143 replies on one page. Any ideas?

http://www.20sb.net/forum/topic/your-latest-post-part-1-new/

Wordpress: 3.9.1
bbPress: 2.5.4
BuddyPress: 2.0.1
BuddyBoss Theme: 3.2.1

[Robkk]

@joeyaberle you have threaded replies activated, threaded replies has no pagination so it shows all the replies on one page

[joeyaberle]

Thanks for your quick reply @robkk, unfortunately that is not the answer I wanted to hear. =P I am hoping that someone else has found a way around this.

[Robkk]

unfortunately that is not the answer I wanted to hear. =P

its the right answer though.

check out these other threads

Regular support topics

Pagination issue when threaded replies are enabled

New feature Enable threaded (nested) replies in bbpress 2.4

Trac topics

https://bbpress.trac.wordpress.org/ticket/2523

Here are some quotes from developers of bbpress

This is the way this feature is currently designed. Hierarchical pagination is quite challenging to tackle; WordPress provides some help with this, but it wasn’t built into our first pass, and no work has gone into improving it since.

This is actually by design, when reply threading is activated pagination is disabled.

its possible though , i see this site is running bbpress, has threaded replies and pagination.
But it all might be custom development.

The Damn Good Music List #2