Thanks for the feedback Jared! I was finally able to take a minute to figure out that the problem is the theme. Do you know how I can figure out why the theme is causing this problem?
Soukos, after doing a bit of digging, I figured out how to resolve the issue we were both having – User registration is currently not allowed.
In your dashboard, go to Settings > General, and click “Allow anyone to register”
I’m having the same issue when trying to register an account.