So I have the issue resolved.
I checked the box to let bbPress Notify (no spam) “Override subscriptions” so that this plugin handles those replies.
I am using bbpress notify (no spam). I just dropped the no spam part in the post.
I am ok with the Bcc. Just need to figure out how to ensure bbpress notify (no spam) does not interfere with the notifications from subscriptions.
The alternative would be default all users to be subscribers to all forums. Is there a plugin for that? Or else may need some code or direct database changes to implement that.
I disabled bbpress Notify and found that the notifications to replies/subscription is working.
I had NOT set bbpress notify to override bbpress subscriptions, so not sure why it was still disabling those notifications.
However, the email seem to have been addressed to noreply@domain, with the user email Bcc’ed
Is that how the notifications are sent? Not sure where the noreply@ was set, there is no such email in the system, so it will bounce.
Sorry the subject line was possibly misleading.
I am expecting that when some one posts a reply, then the original author is notified by email that he/she has had a reply. (Just as I got an email when you replied to this)
That is the email that is not is not being sent.
Currently the author needs to check back on the forum frequently to see if there are any replied.
