[Martyn Chamberlin]

Hi folks,

I’m using BBPress over at raisingharmony.com/forums/. It is a premium content area, meaning you can’t access the forum without proper login credentials. I would be happy to provide some if it would assist in troubleshooting. My trouble is that when people checkmark the checkbox that says, “Notify me of follow-up replies via email,” they aren’t getting the email.

Couple of notes:

(1) I’m using WordPress 3.4.2.
(2) I’m using BBPress 2.1.2.
(3) The PHP mail() function works just fine on the rest of the site.
(4) My only modification to the plugin is that in the /wp-content/plugins/forums/bb-includes/bbp-common-functions.php file, I’ve updated the bbp_check_for_floodI() function to return “True” every time, but this shouldn’t be affecting the email functionality in any way.

Just googling around and looking on this forum, it looks like other people have complained about this 13 months ago, but nobody ever posted an answer other than, “Cool, it’s working now.”

Any suggestions?

Thanks!
Martyn Chamberlin

[Lynq]

Hey,

I had an issue with this and wrote a small plugin which seemed to of resolved it.
http://pastebin.com/ADfuRHiH

Not sure if it is still an issue but before adding this plugin it did not always work (it did sometimes) and after it seems to work all the time, it can still go into spam though.

Good luck!

[Martyn Chamberlin]

Hi Lynq,

Bummer! I activated your little plugin, but this didn’t do the trick. Still not getting email notifications.

I’m thinking the problem must be specific to BBPress since the primary WP emails are going out just fine.

Any other suggestions?

[nightshift58]

When a reply is stored and “Notify me…” is checked, the subscription request is not stored in wp_usermeta.

As such, subsequent queries to retrieve the subscribers yield none.

If I manually add a record in wp_usermeta, the notification is then sent as expected.

Best,
Bob
iMember360.com

[Martyn Chamberlin]

Oh my goodness. That’s crazy! Sounds like a serious error on the part of BBPress.

What do you suggest we do about this?

[nightshift58]

In includes/replies/functions.php, bbp_udate_reply() is not receiving $author_id.

Subsequently, the call to bbp_get_current_id() is failing (whereas wp_get_current_user(), when added, is not failing).

Considering that we’re on v2.2.2, it’s strange to see such basic errors creep up.

Best,
Bob
iMember360.com

[nightshift58]

I’ve added a filter to iMember360 so that the correct $author_id is returned.

Best,
Bob
iMember360.com

[jeffredbeardconsulting]

I’m having the same failure of the “Notify me of follow-up replies via email” box. When I reply to a post and check the “Notify me of follow-up replies via email” box and reply to the post I get no email. However, if I go back and select “Edit” for my post and re-check the “Notify me of follow-up replies via email” box then all replies to the post result in an email to me. Why is the initial input box not responding? I am using bbPress 2.5.2.